As a business owner looking to prepare your business for an eventual sale, and maximize its valuation, there are a number of relevant intellectual property law issues to consider before and during the sale/purchase process. Here are three of the most important.
Ownership
There can be substantial value in your company's intellectual
property, but only if your company actually owns, or has valid
licenses to use, all intellectual property that is used in its
business. Never assume you own your IP, properly confirm it by: (i)
reviewing all intellectual property agreements (such as
assignments, license agreements and prior sale and purchase
documents) with third parties that show you have been granted
ownership or at a minimum the right to the third party intellectual
property; and (ii) by confirming that all of your employees and
contractors (who have or will create some or all of the relevant
intellectual property) have proper written employment agreements
and/or agreements assigning ownership of all intellectual property
and technology they develop. Without these agreements, ownership of
inventions (whether or not patentable) may initially belong to the
inventor and not the company.
Intellectual property agreements
Review your intellectual property agreements carefully. For
in-licensing agreements (where your company receives a license to
use third party intellectual property), a buyer will want to
confirm that the
scope of the license is broad enough to cover all current and
anticipated future uses of the licensed intellectual property
(including the right to make and own modifications and derivative
works, if applicable). Also, consider and assess grants of
exclusive rights, including an exclusive license to use
intellectual property for a particular field of use or the
appointment of an exclusive distributor or reseller in a specific
territory or market. Potential buyers may already have their own
established distribution networks and the exclusive rights you
would grant as part of the sale may cause channel or development
issues and/or de-value the intellectual property assets in the eyes
of a buyer. And, importantly, check your in-licenses to make sure
you have the right to assign the rights and obligations to any
buyer, so the agreements can continue after the sale of the
business is completed.
Review your out-licensing agreements (where a license is granted to a third party customer or partner to use your company's intellectual property), to make sure the scope of the license is appropriate and that only those rights needed by the licensee are granted and not more. If you have indemnification provisions, check them carefully. Buyers will be very interested to make sure that any indemnity rights granted to third parties are limited by appropriate limitation of liability provisions (such as appropriate damage caps).
Registered intellectual property
Examine all materials related to your registered intellectual
property, including patents and applications for patent, trademarks
and trademark applications, copyright (registered and
unregistered), and any Internet domain names. A prospective
purchaser will want to confirm that your company is properly
registered as the owner of record for all such items and that all
required filings are current and up to date to maintain the
registrations in good standing.
For a seller looking to obtain or maintain the highest
valuation, the above-noted intellectual property issues must be
carefully considered.