These tips helped double subscribers on Vero's own blog in just 4 weeks.
Personalize the various calls to action you customers see when interacting with the various sections of your site.
If you're running a blog, make your subscription calls to action relate directly to the blog post they're reading. In the example below, the call to action targets readers of our 6 email marketing lessons you can learn from Amazon post. The post introduces eCommerce readers to lifecycle email so we are aiming to provide even more valuable content in the call to action.
If you are running an eCommerce store you should insert and personalize subscribe forms where relevant. The classic 'be notified when this product is available' is a great example of a way to get subscribers onto one of your email lists, even if it's just to send them a notification at first.
If you're really savvy you could go as far as letting subscribers get notifications on other users, properties or products based on their preferences. This sort of personalization is attractive to new subscribers.
Qualaroo is a simple product that makes it easy to ask simple questions of your site visitors. Using their workflows you can create mini-funnels within your surveys.
For example, if you ask blog visitors these questions:
You can send customers who click the 'This is my first post' answer to a subscribe form, like so:
You'd be surprised how well this works.
Using your analytics data you should be able to identify sections of your site that have large amounts of traffic with minimal conversion.
The homepage is often one such place: it usually receives a considerable amount of traffic that is relatively targeted (customers have heard of you and either Googled your name or clicked some promoted link) and this can be a good place to target with popups.
KISSmetrics show how it's done by targeting visitors that are about to bounce with this popup form:
Similarly, Andrew Chen and Gregory Ciotti use full-page interstitail popups for customers that come directly to their blog home pages. This ensures that regular readers are not frustrated and that new readers who have already invested in finding the site do subscribe.